HMRC v Esporta Limited [2013] UKUT 173 (TCC) (26 April 2013)
"VAT –whether First-tier Tribunal erred in concluding that membership fees recovered after access to club's facilities had been denied due to non-payment were not consideration for a supply but compensation – held yes - appeal allowed."
A HTML version of this file is not available click here or view below the pdf version : 173.pdf