Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber)

---

You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) >> Coombs v Information Commissioner and The Buckinghamshire Grammar Schools (Information rights - Freedom of information - public interest test) [2023] UKUT 157 (AAC) (5 July 2023)
URL: http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKUT/AAC/2023/157.html
Cite as: [2023] UKUT 157 (AAC)

---

[New search] [Contents list] [Printable PDF version] [Help]

---

Coombs v Information Commissioner and The Buckinghamshire Grammar Schools [2023] UKUT 157 (AAC) (5 July 2023)

nformation Rights - adequacy of reasons in First-tier Tribunal's decision - first ground of appeal concerned First-tier Tribunal's finding that public authority did not hold information (a statistician's report) despite indications in contemporaneous documentation that the report would be sent to it - Held: First-tier Tribunal's finding was adequately explained, as was based on direct knowledge of witnesses, whom First-tier Tribunal found to be credible and reliable - second ground of appeal concerned First-tier Tribunal's finding of advantage to private tutors, if requested information disclosed - First-tier Tribunal found that "tutors' advantage" was to be given overbearing weight in "public interest benefit test" - exemptions in s41 and s43 Freedom Of Information Act considered - Held: it was not adequately explained as to why the requested information would have the advantageous effect - not sufficient that First-tier Tribunal found respondents' witnesses to be generally credible and reliable, as (i) their opinions were challenged by the appellant; (ii) the challenge was rational and intelligible and (ii) this was a matter of reasoned opinion (not in direct experience of any of the witnesses) - First-tier Tribunal failed to explain why rejected appellant's challenge to the evidence - material error of law - First-tier Tribunal decision set aside - remitted to fresh First-tier Tribunal for rehearing.

A HTML version of this file is not available click here or view below the pdf version : [2023] UKUT 157 (AAC)