For the whole decision click here: o36000
Summary
The patent application was entitled Real/fantasy competition and related to a type of competition which was particularly relevant to competitive sports. The patent examiner had told the applicant that he had been unable to find anything of a patentable nature in the application on which he could base a search, in view of section 1(2) of the Act, and after further correspondence the applicant requested a hearing. The hearing officer, having identified the contribution that the invention made to the known art of sporting competitions, held that the contribution was not technical in nature. The fact that a programmed computer could be used to implement the invention did not introduce a technical element into the invention, since the programmed computer was operating in a conventional manner. The application was therefore refused.