[1] EE Limited, Hutchison 3G UK Limited, TalkTalk Telecom Group PLC, Verizon UK Limited and Vodafone Limited

[2] Statement at [8.10]

[5] See the Statement at [8.12]

[10] June BCMR Consultation, Annex 5, Question 13

[11] Statement at [1.28]

[12] Statement at [1.29] - [1.30]

[13] Statement at [1.31]

[14] Statement at [1.38]

[15] Statement at [8.52]

[16] Mr Culham for Ofcom explained the bandwidth gradient in his first witness statement as follows at [25]:

"The current tariff structures for leased lines generally involve higher bandwidth services making a greater contribution to the recovery of common costs than lower bandwidth services. To put the point another way, the tariff gradient in relation to bandwidth exceeds the gradient of marginal cost in relation to bandwidth. However, charges for additional increments of bandwidth are generally substantially less than proportional to the amount of extra bandwidth purchased (i.e. there is a reduction in average price per unit of bandwidth for higher bandwidth services, so for example a 1Gbit/sec circuit is priced at a significant discount to 10 x 100Mbit/sec circuits)."

[17] Openreach is the name given to the separate BT division created as a result of the 2005 Telecommunications Strategic Review to provide wholesale services to BT and third parties on equivalent terms ("Equivalence of Inputs" or "EoI").

[18] See paragraph 9 above

[19] Statement at [8.76]

[20] Statement at [8.84]

[21] See for example: T-Mobile (UK) Limited v OFCOM (Termination Rate Disputes) [2008] CAT 12 at [82], Albion Water Limited v Water Services Regulation Authority [2008] CAT 31 at [72], British Telecommunications plc v OFCOM (080) [2011] CAT 24 at [230], Telefónica UK Limited v OFCOM [2012] CAT 28 at [45] and British Sky Broadcasting Limited & Ors v OFCOM [2012] CAT 20 at [84]

[23] Transcript of hearing day one, page 4 (lines 5 - 7)

[24] Transcript of hearing day one, page 12 (lines 17 - 20)

[25] Transcript of hearing day three, page 29

[26] See, for example, the Statement at [8.17], [8.43], [9.49] and [8.84]

[27] See paragraph 27 above

[28] See paragraph 155 below

[29] Transcript of hearing day one, page 48 (lines 2 - 9)

[30] Transcript of hearing day three ( in camera)

[31] Transcript of hearing day one, page 21

[32] Transcript of hearing day one, page 5

[33] Transcript of hearing day two, page 17 (lines 21ff)

[34] Transcript of hearing day three ( in camera), page 3 (lines 15-24)

[35] Transcript of hearing day one, page 22 (line 26)

[36] Transcript of hearing day one, page 2

[37] MBNL is a joint venture between EE and Three

[38] Hearing transcript day four, page 72 (lines 3 - 24)

[39] See paragraph 28(d) above

[40] See paragraph 27 above.

[41] City "rings" are where there is typically one large ring around a main node and then smaller rings around sub-nodes (in contrast to hub-and-spoke and point-to-point topologies)

[42] Transcript of hearing day one, page 43

[43] Dr Lilico calls this remedy "retail minus" - see paragraph 165(f) above

[44] Transcript of hearing day two, page 4

[45] Transcript of hearing day one, page 51 (lines 13 - 18)