[1755] Mor 11421
Subject_1 PRESUMPTION.
Subject_2 DIVISION II. Payment when presumed.
Subject_3 SECT. V. Honoraries presumed paid.
Date: Doctor Park
v.
Representatives of Langlands
7 February 1755
Case No.No 88.
Physicians fees are presumed paid, except during the last sixty days of the deathbed sickness.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
Doctor Park, son-in-law to Langlands, pursued his Representatives for furnishings and attendance, as surgeon and physician to the defunct's family, during many years; and, particularly, for his own attendance on Langlands during his last sickness, which lasted for above seven months.
Among other things, objected by the Representatives; That, with respect to the fees stated for attendance as a physician, these are presumed paid at the time of the attendance, except for the attendance of the last 60 days in the deathbed sickness, according to a decision, Doctor Russell against Sir James Dunbar, (supra,) and according to the reasoning in two other decisions, Johnston against Bell, (supra,) and M'Kenzie against Town of Burntisland, (supra.)
Answered for Doctor Park; The honoraries of physicians may be presumed paid at the time of attendance, where the physician and patient are strangers to each other; but that presumption does not take place where the parties are nearly connected together; in that case, it is not probable the fees would be paid with the same regularity with which they are in use to be paid to a stranger.
“The Lords found, That the fees stated by the pursuer, as a physician, are presumed to have been paid, except during the deathbed sickness of the defunct, which they modified.”
N. B. The interlocutor did not express whether fees were presumed not paid during the whole of the last sickness, or only during the last 60 days of it; but the sum modified was so small, that the last seemed to be implied.
For Doctor Park, Brown, J. Dalrymple. Alt. W. Wallace, Miller.
The electronic version of the text was provided by the Scottish Council of Law Reporting