Subject_1 THIRLAGE.
Date: Wedderburn
v.
Durie
8 November 1741
Case No.No. 81.
Effect of the clause cum multuris in the tenendas of a charter.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
It is a known distinction between the import of a tenendas of a charter from a subject and a charter from the Crown, that a clause cum multuris, though only in the tenendas, being in a charter from a subject, is effectual to liberate from thirlage; but where the charter is from the Crown, such clause being only in the tenendas, is of no effect; because signatures, when passed in Exchequer, do not contain the tenendas other than the word tenendas, with an &c. the clause is therefore considered only the work of the writer.
But in this case the question occurred, What should be the effect of such a clause in the tenendas of a charter from a churchman? And though no interlocutor passed on it, it was the opinion of some able Judges, that it ought to have no more effect than in the case of a charter from the Crown, and so is to be presumed to have proceeded from inadvertency, if not in the dispositive clause.
The electronic version of the text was provided by the Scottish Council of Law Reporting