[1679] Mor 14531
Subject_1 SERVITUDE.
Subject_2 SECT. IV. Servitude may be restricted to the necessary Use.
Date: Dunlop
v.
The Laird of Drumalzier
23 January 1679
Case No.No. 32.
A servitude of pasturage of a certain number of sheep on large muirs, found not to give interest to the heritors or tenants to soum or roum, in order that the ground might not be overstocked.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
Mr. Alexander Dunlop being infeft in the vicar-land of Drumalzier, with 48 soums pasturage, to be pastured upon the lands of Drumalzier, pursues a declarator of his right; and that the lands of Drumalzier, out of which this pasturage is, may be soumed, that the possessors thereof may keep no more soums than shall be found their proportion, that by over-souming, the pursuer be not prejudged. The defender alleged, non relevat, because albeit it be true, that where divers heritors have a common pasturage in one commonty, no part whereof is ever ploughed, the said common pasturage may be soumed and roumed, that all the soums the whole commonty can hold, may be determined and proportioned to each roum having the common pasturage, according to the holding of that roum;—but here the defender having the right of property, burdened with a definite servitude of pasturage granted by him by paction or prescription; the said servitude cannot be made heavier or more burdensome than it was constituted, by limiting the proprietor of the free use of his property, by ploughing more or less as he pleases, and using his discretion in keeping his own goods on his own ground; for it can never be presumed, but the proprietor will be more careful, not to overstock his own ground, upon his own account, than upon the account of this servitude.
The Lords found that member not relevant.
The electronic version of the text was provided by the Scottish Council of Law Reporting