[1632] Mor 9454
Subject_1 PACTUM ILLICITUM.
Subject_2 SECT. II. Pactum contra Libertatem.
Date: Laird of Caprington
v.
Geddew
24 March 1632
Case No.No 4.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
One Geddew a collier, gives his bond to the Laird of Caprington, to serve and work at his coal-heughs during all the days of his lifetime. Notwithstanding, he leaves the Laird, and enters in service with the Laird of Craigie-Wallace. Caprington pursues the collier upon his bond. It was alleged, that the bond was made contra bonos mores, and christian liberty, and of the nature of a bond of man rent. The Lords repelled the allegeance.
*** Durie reports this case: In a pursuit against Geddew, for payment of certain sums, for being absent from Caprington's work, at his coal-heugh, contrary to the tenor of Geddew's bond, whereby he had obliged him to work at Caprington's coal-heugh during all the days of his lifetime; and the Laird of Craigie-Wallace, who was master to Geddew compearing to defend him; alleged, that this bond was null, and ought not to be sustained in any christian nation, seeing it was against good manners, and christian liberty, to take any person perpetually bound to a perpetual and miserable servitude, and also against the acts of Parliament, which prohibit all leagues and bonds among the subjects, as the 43d act 6th. Parl. Queen Mary, and 12th act 10th Parl. James VI. For it is against all equity and natural liberty, to take the free liege of his Majesty obliged to perpetual servitude. This allegeance was repelled, and the bond found lawful and sustained.
Act. —— & Gilmor. Alt. ——. Clerk, Gibson.
The electronic version of the text was provided by the Scottish Council of Law Reporting