[1628] Mor 4839
Subject_1 FORUM COMPETENS.
Subject_2 DIVISION V. Arrestment Jurisdictionis Fundandę Gratia.
Subject_3 SECT. V. Reconvention.
Date: Kirkhead
v.
Nairn
9 February 1628
Case No.No 51.
The procurator for a foreigner, pursuer, was found not obliged to find caution judicio sisti et judicatum solvi, in an action of reconvention, proposed to be raised at the instance of the defender.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
In an action betwixt Gerard Kirkhead, procurator for an Englishman, against Mr William Nairne, minister at Dysart, for payment of a sum contained in his obligation, the defender desiring, that the pursuer should be compelled to find caution to him judicio sisti et judicatum solvi, in the pursuit of reconvention, which he had to intent against this pursuer's constituent, whose procurator he was, et cujus nomine agit, seeing he was a stranger, and not subject to this Scottish jurisdiction, and that, both of the law and equity, he ought to be answerable to the defender in his reconvention, the Lords sustained the action at this procurator's instance, and found no necessity that the procurator should find caution to answer in the defender's reconvention against the procurator, as representing his constituent: But here it is to be considered, that there was no action intented against the procurator, as representing the constituent, which it it had been done, I think albeit the Lords found, that the procurator could not be holden to find caution, yet they would not have refused to have ordained himself to be answerable, so that whatsoever he should recover by this process against the defender, the same should remain liable to the defender, in his reconvention, but there was found here no necessity of this, seeing the defender had not intented any action as he might have done.
Act. Russel. Alt. Nairn. Clerk, Gibson.
The electronic version of the text was provided by the Scottish Council of Law Reporting