A brother retoured heir to his father in an annualrent, preferred to his sister who had been retoured heir to the same, when he was abroad, without necessity of reduction.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
In a suspension of the Lo. Colvill against Mr Walter Herd, who was residenter, and dwelt with his family, in Vezon in France; and who, as served and retoured heir to his said umquhile father, craved payment of an annualrent out of the Lo. of Colvill's lands, wherein his said father died infeft; and against Christian Herd, sister to the said Walter, who was retoured heir to her father, in the same annualrent also, before the said Mr Walter's retour, and who had thereupon obtained two sentences before the Lords against the suspenders; and so the brother and sister craving the right thereof, the sister, in respect of her prior retour standing, and sentences foresaid, which she alleged should give her preference, while the same were reduced, seeing also she produced a note of a sentence of excommunication against her brother for papistry, whereby she alleged, that he could enjoy no benefit within the kingdom; and the brother contending, that seeing he was retoured heir, and had of the law the preference to females, the excommunication should not debar him from his civil right, and the right due to him by nature, seeing there was also produced for him a testificate subscribed from the Magistrates of that town where he remained, bearing him yet to be living, and that he had wife and children begotten in lawful matrimony;———The Lords, notwithstanding of the excommunication and prior retours and sentences alleged for the sister, preferred the brother without necessity of reduction; and found, that he ought to be answered in this right; and if he was excommunicate, his right would accresce and pertain to the King, and not to the sister, eo casu.
Act. Primerose et Bruce.Alt. ——.Clerk, Gibson.
Fol. Dic. v. 1. p. 170. Durie, p. 276.
