APPENDIX A
THE LAW COMMISSION'S ROLE AND METHODS
The Law Commission has now been in operation for 38 years. It was established by the Law Commissions Act 1965 to review the law of England and Wales with a view to its systematic development and reform. A number of specific types of reform were mentioned:
• codification
• removal of anomalies
• repeal of obsolete and unnecessary enactments
• consolidation
• generally the simplification and modernisation of the law.
Law reform projects may be included in a programme of work submitted to the Lord Chancellor, or be referred to the Commission usually by a Government department. The current programme of work is the Eighth Programme, approved in 2001. The Commission initiates or accepts a law reform project according to its assessment of the relevant considerations, the most significant of which are the importance of the issues, the availability of resources in terms of both expertise and funding and the suitability of the issues to be dealt with by the Commission. The Commission's general aims for law reform are to make the law simpler, fairer, more modern and cheaper to use.
The Commission's work is based on thorough research and analysis of case law, legislation, academic and other writing, law reports and other relevant sources of information both in the United Kingdom and overseas. It takes full account both of the European Convention on Human Rights and of other European law. It acts in consultation with the Scottish Law Commission. It normally publishes a consultation paper inviting views before it finalises its recommendations. The consultation paper describes the present law and its shortcomings and sets out possible options for reform. The views expressed in response by consultees are analysed and considered very carefully.
The Commission's final recommendations are set out in a report which contains a draft Bill where the recommendations involve primary legislation. The report is laid before Parliament. It is then for the Government to decide whether it accepts the recommendations and to introduce any necessary Bill in Parliament, unless a Private Member or Peer does so. After publication of a report the Commission often gives further assistance to Government Ministers and departments, so as to ensure that the best value is obtained from the effort and resources devoted to the project by the Commission and others.
The Commission also has the task of consolidating statute law, substituting one Act, or a small group of Acts, for all the existing statutory provisions in several different Acts. In addition, the Commission prepares legislation to repeal statutes which are obsolete or unnecessary.