The Law Commission

APPENDIX F

List of persons and organisations who commented on Consultation Paper No 126

GOVERNMENT BODIES

The Crown Office, Master McKenzie QC & Lynne Knapman
The Crown Prosecution Service
The Department of the Environment
The Departments of Health and Social Security
The Home Office
The Government Legal Service (Treasury Solicitor's Group)
The Legal Aid Board
The Lord Chancellor's Department

JUDICIARY AND PRACTITIONERS

(i) Judiciary

Sir Thomas Bingham MR
Lord Justice Carswell
Lord Donaldson of Lymington
Judge Edward, European Court of Justice
Lord Justice Glidewell
Lord Jauncey of Tullichettle
The Nominated Judges of the Queen's Bench Division
Mr Justice Sedley

(ii) Barristers

Lord Alexander of Weedon QC
Andrew Arden QC
Peter Bibby
Sir Louis Blom-Cooper QC
David Dethridge
Sir Denis Dobson QC
Roger ter Haar QC
Lancelot Henderson
R A Henderson QC
John Howell QC
Francis Jacobs QC
Michael Kent
Nigel Macleod QC
Judith Maxwell
G E Moriarty QC
David Pannick QC
Nigel Pleming QC
Peter Prescott QC
Michael Shrimpton
Malcolm Spence QC
Roger Toulson QC
David Watkinson, Housing Law Practitioners, 2 Garden Court
Frances Webber, Immigration Group, 2 Garden Court

(iii) Solicitors

Clarke Willmott & Clarke
Clifford Chance (Richard Thomas)
Denton Hall (Stephen Ashworth)
Freshfields (SJ Archer)
Peter Liell
Lovell White Durrant (Jennifer McDermott)
Nelsons (J Roberts)
Sharpe Pritchard (Trevor Griffiths)
Sturtivant & Co (Karen L Sturtivant)
Walker Martineau (E J R Hill)
Winstanley-Burgess (David Burgess)

(iv) Legal Organisations

Administrative Law Bar Association
Belfast Law Centre
City of London Law Society
Environmental Law Foundation
Hounslow Law Centre
The Institute of Legal Executives
JUSTICE
Law Centres Federation
The Law Society
The Law Society's Revenue Law Committee
London Solicitors Litigation Association
The Public Law Project
UK Environmental Law Association

(v) Other Lawyers

Roger Bronkhurst, Tottenham Neighbourhood Law Centre (personal capacity)
H Levenson, Chairman, Independent Tribunal Service (personal capacity)

ACADEMIC LAWYERS

Professor John E Alder, University of Keele
Professor Stephen Bailey, University of Nottingham
Nicholas Bamforth, Wadham College Oxford
Professor John S Bell, University of Leeds Law Faculty
Professor Patrick Birkinshaw, University of Hull
Peter Cane, Corpus Christi College Oxford
Roger Cockfield, De Montfort University
Francis Coleman, University of East Anglia
P P Craig, Worcester College Oxford
Ian G Cram, University of Leeds
Professor S M Cretney QC, University of Bristol
Professor Keith Davies, University of Reading
Brian Downrick, Cardiff Law School
Dr M A Fazal, Nottingham Trent University
Professor D J Feldman, University of Birmingham
Mark Gould, University of Bristol
Professor Carol Harlow, London School of Economics
Professor Martin Loughlin, University of Manchester
Ian Macleod, London Guildhall University
Sir Derek Oulton, GCB, QC, Magdalene College Cambridge
Ilona Perkins, Monica Kurnatowska, Jane Flannery & Tanya Nash (students of law, University of Essex)
Professor H M Purdue, University of Newcastle upon Tyne
Dr Paul Robertshaw, Cardiff Law School
Belinda Schwehr, University of Westminster
A P Le Sueur, University College London
Brian Thompson, University of Liverpool
Dr Christopher Vincenzi, University of Huddersfield
Sir William Wade QC, Gonville & Caius College Cambridge
S M Wright, University of Surrey
Professor I Zamir, Hebrew University of Jerusalem

FROM LOCAL AUTHORITIES

(i) Response on behalf of an Authority

Society of County Secretaries, GD Gordon
Croydon Borough Council, Mrs DM King
Royal Borough of Kingston, Miss S Jackson
Tower Hamlets Borough Council, Ms Ann Drake

(ii) Response from an individual member of a Local Authority

E J Andrews, Northavon District Council
Helmut Cartwright, East Sussex County Council
W J Church, Hertfordshire County Council
W Croydon, Swale Borough Council
Clive Grace, Southwark Borough Council
J R Gregory, Staffordshire County Council
Mr Harding, Norfolk County Council
R J Humphries, Durham County Council
J H Jessup, Surrey County Council
R M Kelly, Gateshead Metropolitan Borough Council
M B Kenny, Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council
D W P Lewis, Bristol City Council
Walter Million, Bromley Borough Council
R J B Morris, Northampton Borough Council
Clive Moys, Merton Borough Council
E D Nixon, North Tyneside Council
Miss Phillips, West Sussex County Council
John Polychronakis, Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council
C S Rowland, Oxfordshire County Council
Gordon Smith, Enfield Borough Council
A R Sykes, City of Bradford Metropolitan Borough Council

INTEREST GROUPS AND TRADE UNIONS

Child Poverty Action Group
Council for the Protection of Rural England
English Heritage
Family Health Services Appeal Unit
Greenpeace, with the Anglers Co-operative Association, the RSNC-Wildlife Trusts Partnership, the World Wide Fund for Nature, the RSPB, and Friends of the Earth
Liberty
National Consumer Council
The Newspaper Society
Police Federation of England and Wales
The Royal Town Planning Institute
Transport and General Workers Union

REGULATORS AND OMBUDSMEN

Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, W K Reid CB
The Commission for Local Administration in England, D C M Yardley
The Commission for Local Administration in Wales, E R Moseley
Mental Health Act Commission
Securities and Investments Board

TRIBUNALS

The Council on Tribunals
The Immigration Appeals Adjudicators
The President and Vice Presidents of the Immigration Appeal Tribunal
Stephen Oliver QC, Presiding Special Commissioners of Income Tax and the Chairmen of VAT Tribunals

OTHERS

Mrs V Cornish
Dr Christopher John Eaglen