European Court of Human Rights

You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> European Court of Human Rights >> CINICI v TURKIYE & Ors - 47025/22 ((Art. 6) Right to a fair trial - (Art. 7) No punishment without law : Communicated Case) [2024] ECHR 367 (29 April 2024)
URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2024/367.html
Cite as: [2024] ECHR 367

[New search] [Contents list] [Help]

Published on 29 April 2024

SECOND SECTION

Application no. 47025/22
Muhammet ÇİNİCİ against Türkiye
and 199 other applications
(see list appended)
communicated on 16 April 2024

STATEMENT OF FACTS

1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.

The circumstances of the case

2. The applications mainly concern the applicants' conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the "Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure" (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as "the FETÖ/PDY"), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016.

3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia, on their alleged use of the encrypted messaging application "ByLock", which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY's hierarchical structure.

4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).

Relevant domestic law and practice

5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-93).

COMPLAINTS

6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 § 1.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial) (conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia, on the applicants' alleged use of the encrypted messaging application "ByLock"):

No.	Application no.	Case name	Lodged on	Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality	Represented by
1.	47025/22	Çinici v. Türkiye	28/02/2022	Muhammet ÇİNİCİ 1987 Manisa Turkish	Fatma ÇİNİCİ
2.	47102/22	Özsözen v. Türkiye	26/09/2022	Tamer Alpay ÖZSÖZEN 1977 Samsun Turkish	Yakup GÖNEN
3.	47168/22	Tomar v. Türkiye	13/09/2022	Hasan Duran TOMAR 1976 Çorum Turkish	Memnune Melike AKYILDIZ
4.	47215/22	Bayram v. Türkiye	20/09/2022	Kazım BAYRAM 1976 Giresun Turkish	Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
5.	47265/22	Demir v. Türkiye	19/09/2022	Mehmet DEMİR 1975 Düzce Turkish	İlyas TEKİN
6.	47294/22	Tuskan v. Türkiye	01/09/2022	Mehmet TUSKAN 1968 Adana Turkish	Remziye ARSLAN KAYA
7.	47502/22	Öztürk v. Türkiye	07/09/2022	Eyüp ÖZTÜRK 1973 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
8.	47515/22	Kotan v. Türkiye	14/09/2022	Ümit KOTAN 1976 Samsun Turkish	Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
9.	47542/22	Temel v. Türkiye	07/10/2022	Mehmet Emin TEMEL 1986 Istanbul Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
10.	47549/22	Kayabaş v. Türkiye	05/10/2022	Selman KAYABAŞ 1986 Muğla Turkish	Eda KAYABAŞ
11.	47596/22	Binboğa v. Türkiye	28/09/2022	Halime BİNBOĞA 1986 İzmir Turkish	Yavuz Selim ÇELİK
12.	47774/22	Sözen v. Türkiye	29/09/2022	Yaşar SÖZEN 1980 Samsun Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
13.	47891/22	Fatma v. Türkiye	23/09/2022	Aydın FATMA 1988 Turkish	Akın DEMİR
14.	47952/22	Arslan v. Türkiye	07/09/2022	Yılmaz ARSLAN 1978 Ankara Turkish	Rümeysa DENİZ
15.	47979/22	Vurdem v. Türkiye	03/10/2022	Ümit Erkan VURDEM 1968 Kayseri Turkish	Yasemin Berna ASLANBAY
16.	48005/22	Aldır v. Türkiye	03/10/2022	İsmail ALDIR 1978 Sivas Turkish	Tolgahan KAŞKAYA
17.	48127/22	Sezer v. Türkiye	26/09/2022	Yüksel SEZER 1968 Ankara Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
18.	48139/22	Demirel v. Türkiye	30/09/2022	Mustafa DEMİREL 1987 Antalya Turkish	Başak KARATAŞ
19.	48168/22	Şanda v. Türkiye	05/10/2022	Uğur ŞANDA 1987 Ankara Turkish	Nesibe YOLCU
20.	48186/22	Kuzan v. Türkiye	30/09/2022	Ertuğrul KUZAN 1984 Istanbul Turkish	Fatma ALBAYRAK
21.	48311/22	Kılıç v. Türkiye	03/10/2022	Mehmet KILIÇ 1987 Osmaniye Turkish	Mehmet Ali KAYA
22.	48337/22	Diler v. Türkiye	25/09/2022	Metin DİLER 1971 Erzurum Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
23.	48358/22	Kaya v. Türkiye	03/10/2022	Aydın KAYA 1980 Ankara Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
24.	48389/22	Mecit v. Türkiye	04/10/2022	Hamit MECİT 1972 Malatya Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
25.	48507/22	Kaçmaz v. Türkiye	22/09/2022	Fahri KAÇMAZ 1983 Samsun Turkish	Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
26.	48528/22	Koca v. Türkiye	10/10/2022	Tuba KOCA 1987 Jørpeland (Norway) Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
27.	48660/22	Boduroğlu v. Türkiye	10/10/2022	Özkan BODUROĞLU 1984 Kastamonu Turkish	Şeyma ALKAN
28.	48904/22	Yılmaz v. Türkiye	07/10/2022	Aydın YILMAZ 1979 Ankara Turkish	Ertuğrul ALKILIÇ
29.	49119/22	Deniz v. Türkiye	06/10/2022	Muhammed Emin DENİZ 1991 Gaziantep Turkish	Murat CENGİZ
30.	49329/22	İşçi v. Türkiye	13/10/2022	Mehmet İŞÇİ 1983 Kars Turkish	İsmail DOĞAN
31.	49347/22	Mimaroğlu v. Türkiye	19/09/2022	Esra MİMAROĞLU 1984 Hatay Turkish	Abdülgani MİMAROĞLU
32.	49577/22	Yılmaz v. Türkiye	05/10/2022	Murat YILMAZ 1985 Denizli Turkish	Ali KAVALLI
33.	49611/22	Palabıyık v. Türkiye	12/10/2022	Ozan PALABIYIK 1984 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
34.	49820/22	İşçi v. Türkiye	14/10/2022	Reşat İŞÇİ 1973 Turkish	Mustafa ÖZTÜRK
35.	50019/22	Tobi v. Türkiye	05/10/2022	Kadir TOBİ 1987 Turkish	Muhammet DEMİREL
36.	50058/22	Öztürk v. Türkiye	10/10/2022	Yakup ÖZTÜRK 1992 Karaman Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
37.	50220/22	Çelik v. Türkiye	11/10/2022	Zeynep ÇELİK 1977 Manisa Turkish	Mustafa ASLAN
38.	50335/22	Karaoğlu v. Türkiye	22/10/2022	Gülay KARAOĞLU 1972 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Mehmet MİRZA
39.	50456/22	Özel v. Türkiye	14/10/2022	Sabiha ÖZEL 1975 Gaziantep Turkish	Önder ALKURT
40.	50570/22	Lale v. Türkiye	13/10/2022	Melih LALE 1987 Mersin Turkish	Osman ALANBAY
41.	50653/22	Akça v. Türkiye	21/10/2022	Musa AKÇA 1964 Ankara Turkish	Şeyma ALKAN
42.	51117/22	Konukman v. Türkiye	12/10/2022	Tuğrul KONUKMAN 1985 Hatay Turkish	Bilal ÇÖRTÜK
43.	51144/22	Demir v. Türkiye	24/10/2022	Önder DEMİR 1969 Osmaniye Turkish	Emine Hatice DEMİR
44.	51313/22	Demir v. Türkiye	21/10/2022	Mehmet DEMİR 1987 Adana Turkish	Belma KAYRAN
45.	51375/22	Eroğlu v. Türkiye	10/10/2022	Ömer Faruk EROĞLU 1981 Kocaeli Turkish	İlyas TEKİN
46.	51483/22	Ecemiş v. Türkiye	02/11/2022	Mustafa ECEMİŞ 1982 Ankara Turkish	Kemal ÇETİNKAYA
47.	51612/22	Metin v. Türkiye	13/10/2022	Yakup METİN 1977 Ankara Turkish	Saadet METİN
48.	51632/22	Özbay v. Türkiye	25/10/2022	Atilla ÖZBAY 1974 Yozgat Turkish	Memnune Melike AKYILDIZ
49.	51882/22	Yazıcı v. Türkiye	27/10/2022	Yavuz YAZICI 1987 Karabük Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
50.	51906/22	Karadenizli v. Türkiye	27/10/2022	Erkan KARADENİZLİ 1977 Eskişehir Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
51.	52097/22	Elgin v. Türkiye	31/10/2022	Şule ELGİN 1987 Elazığ Turkish	Bekir ALBAY
52.	52193/22	Bahadır v. Türkiye	01/11/2022	Şehide BAHADIR 1986 Manisa Turkish	Emine Özge ARSLAN
53.	52225/22	Tomar v. Türkiye	21/10/2022	Mesut TOMAR 1980 Giresun Turkish	Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
54.	52450/22	Sağlam v. Türkiye	26/10/2022	Harun SAĞLAM 1995 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
55.	52653/22	Dinç v. Türkiye	01/11/2022	Ersin DİNÇ 1980 Trabzon Turkish	Muhammed Nuh POLAT
56.	52795/22	Aksoy v. Türkiye	28/10/2022	Safiye AKSOY 1981 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
57.	52885/22	Bayri v. Türkiye	07/11/2022	Ahmet Cevat BAYRİ 1968 Ankara Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
58.	52975/22	Kılıç v. Türkiye	02/11/2022	Kürşat KILIÇ 1985 Kahramanmaraş Turkish	Ali DİNSEVER
59.	53103/22	Doğan v. Türkiye	04/11/2022	Adem DOĞAN 1992 Osmaniye Turkish	Mehmet Ali KAYA
60.	53199/22	Ağırbaş v. Türkiye	10/11/2022	Ahmet AĞIRBAŞ 1991 Kayseri Turkish	Metin POLAT
61.	53331/22	Demir v. Türkiye	09/11/2022	Kadir DEMİR 1997 İzmir Turkish	Veli ÇELİK
62.	53409/22	Kara v. Türkiye	02/11/2022	Yunus Emre KARA 1991 Sakarya Turkish	Emrullah POLAT
63.	53431/22	Ülker v. Türkiye	11/11/2022	Osman ÜLKER 1976 München (Germany) Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
64.	53439/22	Ünal v. Türkiye	02/11/2022	Cengiz ÜNAL 1976 Sakarya Turkish	Emrullah POLAT
65.	53463/22	Demirel v. Türkiye	09/11/2022	Bekir DEMİREL 1973 Düzce Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
66.	53590/22	Kaba v. Türkiye	04/11/2022	Ercan KABA 1986 Kocaeli Turkish	Hakan KARAKUŞ
67.	53805/22	Yiğit v. Türkiye	04/11/2022	Mustafa YİĞİT 1981 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
68.	53809/22	Yalçın v. Türkiye	04/11/2022	Davut YALÇIN 1988 Ağrı Turkish	Mehmet Fatih KAYA
69.	53898/22	Akpınar v. Türkiye	11/11/2022	İmdat AKPINAR 1970 Niğde Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
70.	53916/22	Yiğitoğlu v. Türkiye	12/11/2022	Adem YİĞİTOĞLU 1962 Isparta Turkish	Ebubekir DEMİÇ
71.	53950/22	Demirel v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	İshak DEMİREL 1993 Konya Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
72.	53998/22	Yılmaz v. Türkiye	15/11/2022	Mehmet YILMAZ 1970 İzmir Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
73.	54047/22	Ebeş v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Sultan Murat EBEŞ 1987 Ankara Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
74.	54049/22	Çam v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	İbrahim ÇAM 1980 Istanbul Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
75.	54077/22	Erdoğan v. Türkiye	19/10/2022	Sadık Erdal ERDOĞAN 1978 Malatya Turkish	Ahmet PEKTAŞ
76.	54081/22	Duran v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Furkan Fatih DURAN 1989 Nevşehir Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
77.	54084/22	Çulha v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Burak ÇULHA 1998 Denizli Turkish	Nazlı MERT
78.	54089/22	Öztürk v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Üneys Özcan ÖZTÜRK 1958 Denizli Turkish	Nazlı MERT
79.	54092/22	Gür v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Cansu GÜR 1989 Denizli Turkish	Nazlı MERT
80.	54221/22	Yıkılmaz v. Türkiye	19/11/2022	Hasan YIKILMAZ 1969 Bursa Turkish	Muhammed Ali DEMİRCİ
81.	54310/22	Şen v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Havvanur ŞEN 1992 Antalya Turkish	Nazlı MERT
82.	54315/22	Savaş v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Aliye SAVAŞ 1992 Antalya Turkish	Nazlı MERT
83.	54382/22	Ayata v. Türkiye	14/11/2022	Tahir AYATA 1970 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
84.	54437/22	Kaya v. Türkiye	17/11/2022	Dilek KAYA 1976 Kırıkkale Turkish	Merve Elif GÜRACAR
85.	54438/22	Vurmaz v. Türkiye	14/11/2022	Fatih VURMAZ 1984 Malatya Turkish	İsa KARGIN
86.	54460/22	Kırlıoğlu v. Türkiye	09/11/2022	Suat KIRLIOĞLU 1975 Burdur Turkish	Muhammed Sabit CAN
87.	54509/22	Pala v. Türkiye	07/11/2022	Osman PALA 1988 Manisa Turkish	Akkız KARDEŞLER
88.	54527/22	Bayram v. Türkiye	01/11/2022	Hasan Hüseyin BAYRAM 1960 Giresun Turkish	Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
89.	54543/22	Süt v. Türkiye	08/11/2022	Hadis SÜT 1984 Bolu Turkish	Adem DÜZGÜN
90.	54620/22	Demir v. Türkiye	14/11/2022	Tacettin DEMİR 1992 Kahramanmaraş Turkish	Halil ŞAHİN
91.	54683/22	Tunçkol v. Türkiye	14/11/2022	Oğuzhan TUNÇKOL 1988 Osmaniye Turkish	Ömer YÜZGEÇ
92.	54851/22	Gürbudak v. Türkiye	21/11/2022	Nevin GÜRBUDAK 1983 Burdur Turkish	Ahmet KESKİN
93.	54867/22	Yılmaz v. Türkiye	15/11/2022	Ünal YILMAZ 1977 Batman Turkish	Sinan DAĞ
94.	54889/22	Çabalak v. Türkiye	09/11/2022	Arif ÇABALAK 1979 Hatay Turkish	Dudu ERTUNÇ
95.	54940/22	Çelik v. Türkiye	09/11/2022	Tevhit ÇELİK 1987 Istanbul Turkish	Mesut ÖZTÜRK
96.	54942/22	Atilla v. Türkiye	16/11/2022	Halil İbrahim ATİLLA 1982 Karaman Turkish	Adem DÜZGÜN
97.	55086/22	Tuna v. Türkiye	15/11/2022	Meryem Serap TUNA 1978 Kahramanmaraş Turkish	Muhammed Murat POYRAZ
98.	55173/22	Delikanlı v. Türkiye	14/11/2022	Tuba DELİKANLI 1979 İzmir Turkish	Okan ERGÜN
99.	55272/22	Öncü v. Türkiye	22/11/2022	Nebahat ÖNCÜ 1987 Mersin Turkish	Abdulselam DURAN
100.	55300/22	Demirbaş v. Türkiye	22/11/2022	Hasan DEMİRBAŞ 1979 Ankara Turkish	Adnan ZEYBEK
101.	55335/22	Arıkan v. Türkiye	21/11/2022	Murat ARIKAN 1987 Gallen (Switzerland) Turkish	Meliha Gülsüm ŞAHİN SOYTÜRK
102.	55422/22	Arslan v. Türkiye	18/11/2022	Mehmet ARSLAN 1966 Kocaeli Turkish	Yüksel GENÇ
103.	55459/22	Güçlü v. Türkiye	25/11/2022	Uğur GÜÇLÜ 1978 Ankara Turkish	Şeyma ALKAN
104.	55479/22	Bayat v. Türkiye	15/11/2022	Abdulkadir BAYAT 1971 Malatya Turkish	Sinan DAĞ
105.	55494/22	İmir v. Türkiye	14/11/2022	Hüseyin İMİR 1990 Düzce Turkish	Cüneyt GÜLBAŞ
106.	55501/22	Metin v. Türkiye	24/11/2022	Mehmet METİN 1980 İzmir Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
107.	55576/22	Gülbay v. Türkiye	23/11/2022	Kenan GÜLBAY 1975 Eskişehir Turkish	Tülay GÜLBAY
108.	55591/22	Alpaslan v. Türkiye	25/11/2022	Ercan ALPASLAN 1986 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
109.	55613/22	Aytek Şen v. Türkiye	28/11/2022	Medine AYTEK ŞEN 1984 Ankara Turkish	Kübra GÜLAÇTI
110.	55929/22	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	24/11/2022	İsmail YILDIRIM 1985 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
111.	56046/22	Gün v. Türkiye	26/11/2022	Ramazan GÜN 1985 Konya Turkish	Leyla MESUTOĞLU
112.	56223/22	Güney v. Türkiye	18/11/2022	Muhammed Fatih GÜNEY 1987 Konya Turkish	Burcu AKTAŞ EFE
113.	56282/22	Kurtoğlu v. Türkiye	22/11/2022	Akif KURTOĞLU 1983 Bolu Turkish	Adem DÜZGÜN
114.	56345/22	Ertuğral v. Türkiye	15/11/2022	Havva Nur ERTUĞRAL 1985 Çanakkale Turkish	Figen AKDOĞAN
115.	56372/22	Çağlayan v. Türkiye	24/11/2022	Abidin ÇAĞLAYAN 1980 Antalya Turkish	Ebubekir RENK
116.	56462/22	Ulucan v. Türkiye	28/11/2022	Kemal Turhan ULUCAN 1989 Konya Turkish	Bilal DAĞLI
117.	56463/22	Dirier v. Türkiye	29/11/2022	Emine DİRİER 1979 Kilis Turkish	Ebru EKİCİ
118.	56469/22	Çelik v. Türkiye	28/11/2022	Rıfkı ÇELİK 1979 Konya Turkish	Bilal DAĞLI
119.	56753/22	Karabina v. Türkiye	21/10/2022	Yusuf KARABİNA 1974 Istanbul Turkish	Muhammet İkbal DOĞANÇAY
120.	56853/22	Ceyhan v. Türkiye	22/11/2022	Hakan CEYHAN 1978 Kütahya Turkish	Zeynep Bilge CEYHAN
121.	57014/22	Güler v. Türkiye	03/12/2022	Ahmet GÜLER 1973 Antalya Turkish	Ahmet KESKİN
122.	57132/22	Keskin v. Türkiye	01/12/2022	Şeyma KESKİN 1992 Bingöl Turkish	Naim GÜÇDEN
123.	57137/22	Ciğerci v. Türkiye	29/11/2022	Zafer CİĞERCİ 1979 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
124.	57395/22	Polat v. Türkiye	28/11/2022	Harun POLAT 1986 Erzincan Turkish	Sümeyra Nur POLAT
125.	57429/22	Türk v. Türkiye	25/11/2022	İsmail TÜRK 1973 Ankara Turkish	Didem Gizem ERGİN
126.	13/23	Uzun v. Türkiye	06/12/2022	Mehmet UZUN 1989 Konya Turkish	Sibel KELEŞ
127.	15/23	Kurnaz v. Türkiye	01/12/2022	Yaşar KURNAZ 1982 Yozgat Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
128.	37/23	İlhan v. Türkiye	02/12/2022	Mehmet Akif İLHAN 1988 VAN Turkish	Mehmet Ali KAYA
129.	344/23	Doğan v. Türkiye	13/12/2022	Selami DOĞAN 1971 Tokat Turkish	Sümeyye DOĞAN
130.	716/23	Yılmaz v. Türkiye	15/12/2022	Sevda YILMAZ 1980 Antalya Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
131.	717/23	Elgün v. Türkiye	15/12/2022	Ali Ramazan ELGÜN 1973 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
132.	796/23	Tunçyürek v. Türkiye	23/12/2022	Hasan TUNÇYÜREK 1983 Isparta Turkish	Orçun MUŞLU
133.	803/23	Çelik v. Türkiye	14/12/2022	Mustafa ÇELİK 1967 Denizli Turkish	Sümeyra ÇELIK AKINCI
134.	992/23	Arslan v. Türkiye	08/12/2022	Kürşad ARSLAN 1984 Ankara Turkish	Zehra ARSLAN ALKAÇ
135.	1117/23	Kurtuldu v. Türkiye	06/12/2022	Sefa KURTULDU 1986 Sakarya Turkish	Mehmet Ali KAYA
136.	1213/23	Turaç v. Türkiye	22/12/2022	Metin TURAÇ 1987 Antalya Turkish	Yavuz Selim ÇELİK
137.	1980/23	Şahin v. Türkiye	15/12/2022	Şenol ŞAHİN 1975 Hatay Turkish	Dudu ERTUNÇ
138.	2039/23	Yılmaz v. Türkiye	08/12/2022	Murat YILMAZ 1983 Kocaeli Turkish	Ahmet Can DEMİRCİ
139.	2051/23	Tüysüz v. Türkiye	21/12/2022	Erol TÜYSÜZ 1973 Kocaeli Turkish	Yakup GÖNEN
140.	2402/23	Kala v. Türkiye	01/12/2022	Osman KALA 1980 Hatay Turkish	Dudu ERTUNÇ
141.	2420/23	Güler v. Türkiye	23/12/2022	İbrahim GÜLER 1971 Çanakkale Turkish	Hatice ÇİLOĞLU
142.	2638/23	Toklu v. Türkiye	16/12/2022	Süleyman TOKLU 1973 Turkish	Halil ÇETİN
143.	2924/23	Işık v. Türkiye	23/12/2022	Mehmet IŞIK 1985 Adıyaman Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
144.	2959/23	Özler v. Türkiye	28/12/2022	Ömer ÖZLER 1981 Erzurum Turkish	Ali KAVALLI
145.	3389/23	Özdemir v. Türkiye	26/12/2022	Mehmet ÖZDEMİR 1979 Aydın Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
146.	4085/23	Çakıroğlu v. Türkiye	09/01/2023	Aynur ÇAKIROĞLU 1990 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
147.	4126/23	Ulus v. Türkiye	27/12/2022	Ünal ULUS 1976 Samsun Turkish	Latife Nazlı GÜVEN
148.	4423/23	Bahadır v. Türkiye	26/12/2022	Mehmet BAHADIR 1988 Manisa Turkish	Mehmet ARSLAN
149.	4645/23	Güngör v. Türkiye	27/12/2022	Yasin GÜNGÖR 1978 İzmir Turkish	Ümmü GÜNGÖR
150.	5044/23	Önder v. Türkiye	19/01/2023	Musa ÖNDER 1972 Kayseri Turkish	Fatih GÜNDÜZ
151.	5053/23	Gündüz v. Türkiye	19/01/2023	Vehbi GÜNDÜZ 1982 Kocaeli Turkish	Fatih GÜNDÜZ
152.	5062/23	Demirkan v. Türkiye	14/01/2023	Ahmet DEMİRKAN 1972 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
153.	5097/23	Zengindemir v. Türkiye	17/01/2023	Mesut ZENGİNDEMİR 1970 Kırıkkale Turkish	Muhammet Uğur DEMİRKAN
154.	5131/23	Çakır v. Türkiye	13/01/2023	Mustafa ÇAKIR 1982 Antalya Turkish	Celil ZURNACI
155.	5227/23	Karakaya v. Türkiye	16/01/2023	Abdulkadir KARAKAYA 1986 Erzurum Turkish	Erdem ALP
156.	5284/23	Mansız v. Türkiye	12/01/2023	Mustafa MANSIZ 1987 Gaziantep Turkish	Dudu ERTUNÇ
157.	5293/23	Yıldız v. Türkiye	16/01/2023	Uğur YILDIZ 1982 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
158.	5336/23	Aksoy v. Türkiye	11/01/2023	Yakup AKSOY 1979 Ankara Turkish	Sinan DAĞ
159.	7156/23	Baki v. Türkiye	28/01/2023	Yasin BAKİ 1975 Ordu Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
160.	7756/23	Alyavuz v. Türkiye	27/01/2023	Osman ALYAVUZ 1972 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
161.	7778/23	Takım v. Türkiye	20/01/2023	Abdulsamet TAKIM 1992 Erzurum Turkish	Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
162.	8441/23	Kazan v. Türkiye	04/02/2023	Burcu KAZAN 1989 Amasya Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
163.	9133/23	Durukan v. Türkiye	08/02/2023	Niyazi DURUKAN 1955 Denizli Turkish	Hayrettin ARABACI
164.	9355/23	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	13/02/2023	Ayhan YILDIRIM 1977 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
165.	9778/23	Özcan v. Türkiye	28/02/2023	Burhan ÖZCAN 1970 Tekirdağ Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
166.	9824/23	Sirkecioğlu v. Türkiye	28/02/2023	İlyas SİRKECİOĞLU 1985 Istanbul Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
167.	12304/23	Başaran v. Türkiye	10/03/2023	Hamdi BAŞARAN 1980 Ankara Turkish	Ahmet Can DEMİRCİ
168.	12533/23	Acar v. Türkiye	07/02/2023	Serap ACAR 1990 Turkish	Adnan ERDOĞAN
169.	12827/23	Çevikel v. Türkiye	09/03/2023	Ersin ÇEVİKEL 1975 Kocaeli Turkish	İlyas TEKİN
170.	12995/23	Dündar v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	Fatih DÜNDAR 1983 Gaziantep Turkish
171.	13273/23	Avşar v. Türkiye	16/03/2023	Güllü AVŞAR 1990 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
172.	13363/23	Doğan v. Türkiye	24/03/2023	Mustafa DOĞAN 1980 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
173.	13768/23	Aktı v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	Songül AKTI 1992 Turkish	Halil ÇETİN
174.	13825/23	Tuğral v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	Elif TUĞRAL 1988 İzmir Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
175.	13829/23	Caymaz v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	Şerife CAYMAZ 1989 Konya Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
176.	13834/23	Özdemir v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	Ayşe ÖZDEMİR 1995 Manisa Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
177.	13836/23	Karakoyun v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	Osman KARAKOYUN 1977 Turkish	Halil ÇETİN
178.	13855/23	Korkmaz v. Türkiye	14/03/2023	İlhan KORKMAZ 1971 Turkish	Halil ÇETİN
179.	14239/23	Aydın v. Türkiye	23/03/2023	Derya AYDIN 1986 Sincan Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
180.	14395/23	Yanık v. Türkiye	24/03/2023	Gıyasettin YANIK 1969 Istanbul Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
181.	14513/23	Bişkin v. Türkiye	27/03/2023	Murat BİŞKİN 1970 İzmir Turkish	Elif GİRGİN
182.	15779/23	Çığcı v. Türkiye	14/04/2023	Mehmet Resul ÇIĞCI 1990 Istanbul Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
183.	16048/23	Korkmaz v. Türkiye	07/04/2023	Hümeyra KORKMAZ 1991 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
184.	16438/23	Mehmet v. Türkiye	17/04/2023	Mete MEHMET 1988 Silivri Turkish	Mehmet ÇAVDAR
185.	17053/23	Ünay v. Türkiye	05/04/2023	Sedat ÜNAY 1973 Kütahya Turkish	Halil ÇETİN
186.	17310/23	Yenilmez v. Türkiye	13/04/2023	Murat YENİLMEZ 1987 Denizli Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
187.	17679/23	Akçay v. Türkiye	03/04/2023	Hüseyin AKÇAY 1975 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
188.	17815/23	Öztürk v. Türkiye	30/03/2023	Mehmet ÖZTÜRK 1970 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
189.	17992/23	Temel v. Türkiye	07/04/2023	Sezgin TEMEL 1974 Giresun Turkish	Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
190.	18012/23	Avşar v. Türkiye	14/04/2023	İbrahim Erkam AVŞAR 1986 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
191.	18309/23	İskender v. Türkiye	03/04/2023	Metin İSKENDER 1973 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
192.	18331/23	Akbaş v. Türkiye	14/04/2023	Ahmet AKBAŞ 1982 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
193.	18687/23	Kılınç v. Türkiye	14/01/2023	Gökhan KILINÇ 1992 Samsun Turkish	Ekrem KAYA
194.	24034/23	Rüzgaresen v. Türkiye	26/05/2023	Ahmet RÜZGARESEN 1985 İzmir Turkish	Nafize GÜLCÜ
195.	24096/23	Yetişkin v. Türkiye	18/05/2023	Mehmet Reşit YETİŞKİN 1980 Ankara Turkish	Burhan DEMİRCİ
196.	26652/23	Dayanır v. Türkiye	04/07/2023	Niyazi DAYANIR 1968 Denizli Turkish	Mehmet MİRZA
197.	26654/23	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	04/07/2023	Türkan YILDIRIM 1984 Denizli Turkish	Mehmet MİRZA
198.	26665/23	Kaplan v. Türkiye	04/07/2023	Abdurrahman KAPLAN 1983 Denizli Turkish	Mehmet MİRZA
199.	28217/23	Küçükçancı v. Türkiye	11/07/2023	Erdem KÜÇÜKÇANCI 1975 Turkish	Halil ÇETİN
200.	28223/23	Acar v. Türkiye	07/07/2023	Ali ACAR 1988 Ankara Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK